I’ve looked at overdrafts and invoice discounting from both sides of the desk. As a banker, I put both in place for business customers, and reviewed them every year. As a finance director, I used both to fund the businesses I worked for.
Neither is better in every case. But I’ve seen plenty of businesses use the wrong one for years, usually because nobody asked the right question.
How a bank really looks at your overdraft
An overdraft is meant to cover short-term swings in cash: a quiet month, a large supplier payment, a customer who pays late. The bank expects the account to move in and out of credit.
When the balance sits at or near the limit month after month, the bank reads it differently. That is what’s known as a hard-core overdraft: borrowing that has become permanent but is still on short-term, repayable-on-demand terms.
When I started in business banking, my boss drilled one question into me whenever an overdraft stopped swinging back into credit: what is it funding? In his view there were only three likely answers:
- Losses. The business is spending more than it earns, and the overdraft is filling the gap.
- Excessive drawings. The owners are taking more out of the business than it can afford.
- Long-term capital spending. Equipment, vehicles, property or an acquisition paid for from the overdraft instead of with a loan matched to the asset.
None of those is what an overdraft is for, and it is exactly what a bank will try to work out at the next review. It’s a question worth answering honestly before the bank asks it.
That matters because an overdraft is usually reviewed once a year and can be reduced or withdrawn. At a review, a hard-core overdraft often leads to a request to reduce the limit, convert it into a term loan, or provide more security. Many owners only discover this when the renewal letter arrives.
How invoice discounting works
Invoice discounting lends against what your customers owe you. When you raise an invoice, the funder advances a percentage of it, typically around 75–80% of approved debts, and releases the balance, less its charges, when the customer pays.
The key difference is that the facility grows with your sales. An overdraft limit is fixed until the bank agrees to change it. An invoice finance facility rises as you invoice more, which is exactly when a growing business needs more cash.
It is also largely self-securing: the invoices themselves are the security. An overdraft often needs tangible security behind it, such as property or a personal guarantee, and there comes a point where the bank won’t increase it, not because the business is doing badly, but because a bigger unsecured or under-secured limit is more risk than it is prepared to take. Invoice discounting doesn’t hit that ceiling in the same way, because each new invoice brings its own security with it. Funders will still usually take a debenture, and sometimes a personal warranty or indemnity, so it isn’t security-free, but it rarely needs property.
With invoice discounting you usually keep control of your own credit control and the arrangement is often confidential, so customers don’t know a funder is involved. With factoring, the funder runs the sales ledger and collects payment for you.
When invoice discounting works better
- The business is growing. More sales mean more debtors and more cash tied up. An overdraft doesn’t move with that; invoice finance does.
- The overdraft has become permanent. Replacing a hard-core overdraft with a facility designed for working capital puts the funding on a sounder footing, and often releases more cash than the overdraft provided.
- The bank won’t go any higher. If the overdraft has reached the limit the bank is comfortable with, or extra headroom would need security you don’t have or don’t want to give, invoice finance can provide more funding secured on your debtors.
- You sell to other businesses on credit terms. Thirty, sixty or ninety-day terms with creditworthy customers are exactly what invoice finance is built for.
- The bank is tightening. If a bank wants to reduce an overdraft, a well-structured invoice finance facility can take its place without the business going short.
When an overdraft is still the right answer
- Cash swings are genuinely short term and the account regularly moves back into credit.
- Debtors are small, or you’re paid quickly, so there isn’t much to lend against.
- Your sales don’t suit invoice finance. Staged or contract billing, applications for payment in construction, heavy reliance on one or two customers, or sales to consumers can all limit what a funder will advance, or rule it out.
- Simplicity and cost matter most. For a business that uses it as intended, an overdraft is cheap and needs very little administration.
What to check before switching
This is where I’d put my FD hat back on. Invoice finance is a good product, but the headline rate doesn’t tell you the cost.
- The all-in cost. There is usually a discount charge on the money you draw and a service fee, often based on turnover, and there may be other charges such as audit, credit protection or minimum fees. Work out the total against how much you’ll actually use.
- The notice period and exit fees. Many facilities have a minimum term or a long notice period. Know how you would get out before you get in.
- Concentration limits. If one customer is a large share of your sales, the funder may cap how much it will advance against that customer.
- What happens to your bank. The invoice finance provider will need first-ranking security over your book debts. If your bank holds a debenture, it will usually need to release its charge over the debts, or agree a deed of priority or a letter of non-crystallisation so the funder ranks first. This can take a few weeks, so raise it early. If your own bank provides the invoice discounting, through its invoice finance arm, this step is usually much simpler, although it’s still worth comparing its terms with independent funders.
- The admin. You’ll need to report sales and keep your debtor ledger tidy. A business with good credit control will find this straightforward; one without it will find it a burden.
Often the answer is both
Many businesses end up with a smaller overdraft for day-to-day movements and an invoice finance facility for working capital, sometimes alongside asset finance for equipment and a term loan or commercial mortgage for property. Matching each type of borrowing to what it is funding is the heart of good debt advisory: it usually costs less, and it makes the business more resilient when one lender changes its appetite.
If you’re an accountant with a client whose overdraft has crept up to its limit, or a business owner facing an overdraft review, it is worth looking at the options before the bank sets the timetable. See invoice and trade finance for more on how it works.
Frequently asked questions
Is invoice discounting more expensive than an overdraft?
Often, on a like-for-like basis, yes, because of the service fee on top of the interest. But the comparison isn’t always like-for-like: invoice finance usually provides more cash and grows with sales, and an overdraft that is about to be reduced isn’t really available at all. The right comparison is the total cost against what each facility actually gives the business.
Can invoice finance replace my overdraft completely?
Sometimes. Many businesses keep a smaller overdraft for day-to-day movements alongside invoice finance. Whether it can replace the overdraft entirely depends on your sales, your customers and how much cash moves through the account.
What happens to my bank’s security if I move to invoice discounting?
The invoice finance provider needs first-ranking security over your book debts. If your bank holds a debenture, which usually includes a charge over book debts, the bank will normally need to release that charge, or sign a deed of priority or a letter of non-crystallisation confirming the funder ranks first over the debts. Your bank can keep its security over other assets, such as property. Agreeing this can take a few weeks, so it’s worth starting early. If your existing bank provides the invoice finance itself, the security is usually dealt with in-house and the process is simpler.
Will my customers know I’m using invoice discounting?
With confidential invoice discounting, usually not: you collect payment from customers as normal. With factoring, the funder manages collections, so customers will know.
What is a hard-core overdraft?
An overdraft that stays at or near its limit for long periods instead of moving in and out of credit. Banks see it as permanent borrowing on short-term terms and will want to know what it is funding, typically losses, excessive drawings or long-term capital spending. It often leads to a request to reduce the limit, convert it into a loan or add security.
Overdraft up for review, or sitting at its limit for months? Send me your latest management accounts and aged debtor list, and I’ll tell you within a working day whether invoice finance would release more cash than your overdraft, and roughly what it would cost. Get in touch.
Accountants: if a client’s overdraft is coming up for renewal, introduce them early. I’ll keep you informed throughout, and the client relationship stays yours. See how introductions work.