I started my career on the bank side of the desk. Looking back, I was sitting in something of an ivory tower. I asked for the management accounts, the cashflow forecast and the aged debtors, and wondered why it all took so long. I offered plenty of advice on how owners could improve their businesses, too.
Then I spent eight years as an FD.
I found out that a business owner’s day isn’t spent thinking only about the numbers. It’s spent setting strategy, pitching for new business, managing the team, moving resources to where they’re needed, and dealing with the client project that’s over budget and over time. Then there’s the problem that turns up at 6pm on a Friday. Finance gets the time that’s left over, which often isn’t much.
When I went back into lending, I wasn’t the same lender. Did I keep a file open longer than some would have? Probably. I was slower to judge a business when the information I’d asked for was late, and more careful about offering opinions on decisions I’d never had to make myself. But I don’t think I asked fewer questions. I asked better ones. Not “why haven’t I got it yet?” but “what’s taking up your time right now?” The answer often told me more about whether the business could repay than the paperwork did. I also asked for what the risk actually needed, not everything on the list. Sometimes that meant less. Sometimes it meant more.
It didn’t always pay off. I once gave a business more time than usual, and the deal still didn’t complete. That one stung. Understanding a business doesn’t guarantee the outcome.
Lenders need rigour. But rigour without understanding can make a lender hard to deal with, and being difficult isn’t the same as being prudent.
That’s where a good broker earns their place. They explain to the owner what credit will ask and why it matters, and they make sure the story behind the numbers is heard before a decision is made.
So, worse lender or better one? I’d say better, for having sat on both sides of the desk. These days I sit closer to the middle.
If you’d like someone who has sat on both sides of the desk to look at your funding, or to prepare a funding proposal that tells the story behind the numbers, get in touch.